An Emerging Norm

By Dilip Cherian

Mallika Srinivasan’s third consecutive one-year extension as chairperson of the Public Enterprises Selection Board (PESB) is increasingly looking less like an exception and more like the emerging norm for key government positions. The preference for continuity at the top, particularly in strategically important roles, has become increasingly evident. Srinivasan’s case fits that pattern.

Her appointment was significant in itself. The first private-sector specialist to head PESB, the government’s headhunter for senior public sector appointments, she represented a departure from the established practice of drawing on the serving or retired bureaucracy. The successive extensions suggest that the government is comfortable with this departure and sees little reason to disrupt an arrangement that appears to be working.

What is also striking, however, is that the PESB chairpersonship has acquired the status of a critical position warranting such sustained continuity. Have PSU leadership appointments become so strategically sensitive that the government prefers a familiar hand at the selection board? Or has the role itself grown in importance as public sector enterprises are being repositioned in the government’s economic agenda?

Whatever the explanation, retaining Srinivasan signals confidence in her stewardship. And if continuity is the government’s preferred approach to important appointments, PESB is clearly no longer an exception.

Army’s battle for bureaucratic parity

The Brigadier may soon become another casualty of India’s curious obsession with bureaucratic parity. The Army is reportedly preparing to abolish the rank, allowing Colonels to move directly to Major General. The proposal, first raised in 2018 under General Bipin Rawat, has now gained fresh urgency, with the 8th Pay Commission offering an opportunity to revisit it.

The grievance is not difficult to understand. An Army officer takes 32–33 years to reach the pay level of a Major General. An IAS or IPS officer can reach the equivalent pay grade in 16–18 years. The military’s steep promotion pyramid leaves precious few officers making it to the top. The civil services, meanwhile, have been considerably more generous in expanding senior grades and designations.

There is perhaps more to this than pay and promotion. The armed forces have long resented the gradual erosion of their relative standing vis-à-vis civilian services, particularly the IAS. Parity has become as much a question of institutional prestige as financial entitlement.

But abolishing a rank is not quite the same as abolishing the responsibility attached to it. Brigadiers command formations; those responsibilities will not disappear with the stars on their shoulders. The Army will have to reconcile its operational requirements with its cadre ambitions.

There is an irony here. The babus have spent decades multiplying grades, designations and avenues of advancement. The Army, finding itself at a disadvantage, now proposes removing a rung from its own ladder to catch up.

Bulldozers move faster than babus

Shastri Bhavan and Krishi Bhavan are headed for the demolition squad, making way for Kartavya Bhawan 4 and 5 under the Central Vista project. The transition to modern, integrated office complexes may be administratively justified, but the haste to clear the old buildings has exposed a rather embarrassing failure of planning.

The most glaring casualty nearly turned out to be the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library, housed in Shastri Bhavan. With over 8.5 lakh books, including rare publications and historical government records, it was initially offered a paltry 300 square metres in the new secretariat. The Culture Ministry rightly rejected the allocation.

It took media scrutiny and, eventually, judicial intervention to shake things up. The Supreme Court has stepped in to save the Central Secretariat Library from being treated as just another pile of material to be shifted. On November 16, it directed the Centre to halt the movement of books until the next hearing, questioning the government’s apparent ad hoc approach and asking it to show some respect for books.

The Centre has since earmarked space for the library, but the episode raises an uncomfortable question: how does a project of this scale reach the demolition stage without a credible relocation plan for an institution of such importance?

Perhaps the obsession with construction deadlines has eclipsed the less photogenic business of preserving institutional assets. Bulldozers, it seems, have a better project-management system than the babudom they are meant to accommodate.

Exit mobile version