New Delhi, June 16: A five-year-old’s description of her ordeal through a Barbie doll has found judicial credence with the Delhi High Court confirming the jail term of a man for sexually assaulting her.
The court said the girl by referring to the private parts of the ‘doll’ conveyed the information as to “what had happened with her”. It noted from the case file that the girl while telling to her doll the ordeal of sexual assault was hesitant to answer “embarrassing”, “derogatory”, “dirty” and “vulgar” questions posed by the defence counsel.
The innovative way of giving a doll to the child to play with, adopted by the trial court judge, yielded results as the high court held that the sentence awarded to the 23-year-old man was based upon proper appreciation of the evidence and it deserves “no intervention”.
Justice S P Garg, while dismissing the appeal filed by the convict, said the five-year-old girl had rightly conveyed the details to the trial court by describing to the doll what all was done to her by the man. The court said merely because no nail marks were found on the private parts of the child, it cannot be inferred that no such incident had taken place and her mother did not permit her internal medical examination to protect her honour.
“The crucial evidence regarding nail marks on the private parts could not be gathered. It, however, does not dilute the oral testimony of the victim whereby by referring to the private parts of the ‘doll’ in her hand she conveyed the information as to what had happened with her. “There was no occasion for the appellant (man) to take the child on the allurement of handing over a Rs 10 note to her brother,” it said.
The incident dates back to July 2014 when the girl was going to school with her 10-year-old brother and accused Hunny gave Rs 10 to the boy and asked him to bring something from a shop and kidnapped the girl. The man took her to Narela in north west Delhi and sexually assaulted her after disrobing and slapping her. He then left the child near her house.
A woman neighbour found the child crying and wandering on streets without her skirt and took her home. Initially, the minor, who was in a state of shock, did not disclose anything to her family, she later told her mother about the incident.
Press Trust of India