Santosh Kumar Mohapatra
The World Bank’s latest estimates of a massive reduction in poverty in India between 2011–12 and 2023–24 have provided the government with considerable ammunition for self-congratulation. However, such statistical triumphalism often risks overlooking the complex economic and social realities confronting millions of households. Unemployment, widening inequality, stagnant real wages, inadequate purchasing power, rising household indebtedness and the growing unaffordabili ty of healthcare and education present a far more complicated picture of economic well-being. The issue is not whether pov erty has declined, but whether its magnitude and pace are being measured with sufficient consistency, transparency and statistical reliability. The World Bank’s own findings reveal continuing vulnerabilities.
Approximately 23.2 crore people remain below its $4.20-a-day lower-middle-income poverty threshold. Its October 2026 Poverty and Equity Brief also highlighted substantial earnings inequality, with median earnings among the top 10% of workers approximately 13 times those of the bottom 10%. In June 2025, following the adoption of updated 2021 Purchasing Power Parities (PPP), the World Bank revised its international poverty thresholds. The extreme poverty line increased from $2.15 to $3.00 per person per day, the lower-middle-income poverty line from $3.65 to $4.20, and the upper-middle-income poverty line from $6.85 to $8.30.These thresholds represent different levels of monetary deprivation. The $3 threshold measures extreme poverty and is derived from the median of national poverty lines in 23 low-income countries. The $4.20 threshold is relevant for lower-middle-income economies such as India, while the $8.30 benchmark highlights the distance between India’s living standards and those associated with upper-middle-income economies.
The World Bank does not independently conduct household poverty surveys in India. It relies on consumption data collected by India’s National Statistical Office (NSO), applying its own international pover ty thresholds and methodology. Therefore, the reliability of its estimates depends heavily on the quality and comparability of Indian surveys. The 2022–23 and 2023–24 Household Consumption Expenditure Surveys adopted the Modified Mixed Reference Period (MMRP), whereas earlier surveys used different recall methods. The World Bank’s May 2025 methodology note acknowledges that the 2011–12 and 2022–23 surveys are not strictly comparable, despite adjustments to improve comparability.
India’s last officially adopted national poverty estimates were based on the Tendulkar Committee methodology and the 2011–12 NSS consumption survey. The subsequent 2017 18 survey was withheld by the government, citing data-quality concerns. Reports suggested that it indicated declining household consumption expenditure, raising concerns about deteriorating living standards and possible increases in pov erty. The absence of this survey leaves a significant gap in understanding poverty trends. International poverty is measured using Purchasing Power Parity rather than prevailing market exchange rates. PPP accounts for differences in the cost of living and the purchasing power of currencies across countries. An important methodological question concerns the PPP conversion factor used to translate the international poverty threshold into Indian rupees.
In 2021, India’s household and Non-Profit Institutions Serving Households (NPISH) consumption PPP, including housing, was 19.47 per international dollar, whereas the individual household consumption PPP excluding housing was 22.58. Housing expenditure changes the relative price of the consumption basket because housing is considerably more expensive in the US than in India. At the $3-a-day poverty threshold, these two conversion factors yield approximately 58.41 and 67.74 per person per day, respectively, in 2021 prices. The latter represents a substantially higher threshold. If the higher conversion factor were applied consistently to the same household welfare distribution, it could classify more people as extremely poor. The World Bank acknowledges that social transfers, including subsidised food grains, contributed to poverty reduction across regions and demographic groups.
However, poverty reduction through publicly funded transfers must be distinguished from improvements resulting from higher regular earnings, better employment and sustainable income-generating opportunities. A historical comparison is also revealing. Poverty declined by an average of 2.18 percentage points annually during 2004–05 to 2011–12, compared with approximately 2.04 percentage points during 2011–12 to 2023–24 under the World Bank’s $3 measure. This comparison challenges the impression that the recent annual pace of poverty reduction was unprecedented. The real test of development is not merely how many people cross a statistical threshold, but how many achieve stable livelihoods, rising purchasing power and a dignified life.
The writer is an Odisha-based economist and columnist.




































