A glass is full for whom?

Santosh Kumar Mohapatra

Santosh Kumar Mohapatra

By Santosh Kumar Mohapatra

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has revived his familiar “glass half full and half empty” analogy to criticise critics questioning India’s recent economic performance.

Defending the latest GDP growth figure, he suggested that for such “naysayers”, the glass will remain half empty and that those responsible for pushing the country into the “Fragile Five” would find the 7.8 per cent growth difficult to digest.

The metaphor represents different ways of looking at reality. The optimist focuses on what is present, while the pessimist focuses on what is missing. Modi offered a third interpretation—the glass is full, with half water and half air. This, however, raises a more fundamental question: if the glass is full, for whom is it full? And if it is half empty, who is experiencing that emptiness, and why do they continue to suffer despite high economic growth?

Economic comparisons require context. Comparing the present administration with the worst phase of the previous regime, particularly during external crises, can create a misleading benchmark.

The growth figure has also generated debate about its methodology and relationship with indicators such as rupee depreciation, investment flows and inflation.

More importantly, GDP growth must ultimately be judged by its impact on people’s lives. The central issue is not merely how large the economy has become, but how widely the benefits of growth are distributed. For millions of ordinary Indians, the concerns are more immediate: a secure job, a decent income, affordable education and healthcare, adequate housing, food security and the ability to provide their children with a better future.

Crores of Indians continue to face difficulties securing basic necessities such as food, clean water, shelter and healthcare. More than 80 crore people receive subsidised foodgrains under the Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Anna Yojana (PMGKAY), raising questions about purchasing power, employment and economic security.

Climate change and inflation can further intensify these vulnerabilities.

The contrast between impressive GDP numbers and the lived economic reality of large sections of the population therefore deserves attention.

Economists such as Raghuram Rajan have argued that strong headline growth has not translated sufficiently into employment generation and broad-based improvements in real wages. High GDP growth can coexist with weak mass consumption when purchasing power remains concentrated.

This is why the character of growth matters as much as its speed. India’s recovery has often been described as “K-shaped”, suggesting that stronger sections have benefited more rapidly while weaker sections have struggled.

Luxury consumption may rise even as ordinary families face rising costs of food, housing, healthcare and education. Income concentration can further limit social mobility.

Young people face unemployment and underemployment alongside shortages of teachers, doctors and other essential personnel. Public expenditure on health and education remains inadequate. According to NITI Aayog, only about 8.25 per cent of graduates are employed in roles aligned with their qualifications. Its report on skilling for Viksit Bharat estimates that around 8.7 crore young people aged 15–29 are NEET—neither in education, employment nor training.

Therefore, the debate should not be reduced to whether the glass is half full or half empty. The more important questions are: Who owns the glass? Who gets the water? And who is still standing outside without a glass at all?

Economic growth becomes meaningful when it translates into employment, rising purchasing power, accessible healthcare and education, social security and a dignified life.

A country may celebrate a “full glass” at the macroeconomic level, but the real test lies in whether ordinary citizens can drink from it. Progress should ultimately be measured by the quality of life of the last person.

The glass may be technically full—but full for whom?

The author is an Odisha-based economist and columnist.

Exit mobile version