Between Trust & Tensions

By Manavik Raj

History is replete with timelines, often providing a frame of reference in a given period. Will James Durant, the prominent American historian and philosopher, chronicled India in his writings, viewing the country as the “motherland of our race”. After the two world wars and up to the end of the Cold War, history had been at odds with the East. China and India, two enduring civilizations, confounded the West.

India-US relations date back decades, with both proponents and detractors in their time. The Cold War era (1947-1991), the economic pivot (1991-2004), and the global strategic partnership (2005-present) share a trajectory, steering diplomatic sangfroid into political leadership. From Dwight D. Eisenhower to Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, Barack Obama, and Donald J. Trump, the India-US relationship has matured.

India-US ties have strategically deepened since the end of the Cold War. The international strategic environment, the Indian diaspora and its vibrant market paved the way forward. Ashley J. Tellis, a member of the U.S. team who negotiated with India on the Nuclear Agreement, had spoken at length about the Bush administration’s view of India. At the time, China was a bone of contention in the White House. Meenakshi Ahamed, in her masterpiece ‘A Matter of Trust’, writes that when Indian domestic politics became contentious, the Indian bureaucracy cemented this relationship.

Since 1991, there have been a number of proposals and agreements that built the foundation for diplomacy. While defence cooperation kicked off during this phase, the main contention for the Indian government was technology transfer and India’s equation with Pakistan. New Delhi’s negotiations with Washington had always been firm on certain grounds.

With the coming of the Modi government in 2014, various agreements took shape over the years. President Joe Biden announced the Indo-Pacific strategy, noting geopolitical shifts and challenges.

The clashes over the South China Sea determined the course for like-minded countries through the creation of minilaterals and strategies over multilateralism. Under the Initiative on Critical and Emerging Technology (iCET) framework, INDUS-X aligned military cooperation to be concordant with technological and industrial capability.

During the Trump administration the ‘America First’ doctrine viewed world affairs through a bilateral lens rather than strengthening global alliances. There were pleasant exchanges in the first term, but also areas of discord. The ‘Howdy Modi’ event in the U.S. was attended by 50,000 Indian Americans. Moreover, the pandemic (in 2020) created the potential to change the world order. Media wars were rife during this period. The ‘Black Lives Matter’ campaign, coverage of the Galwan Valley conflict, and the U.S. exit from the Paris Agreement were prime-time news in the global media. From then on, a lot of events have transpired.

The Trump administration’s reciprocal tariff hikes against seventy countries made India’s consumer goods uncompetitive against those of various countries. The administration had imposed 25 % punitive tariffs on imports from India, as New Delhi prioritised Russian crude oil. This created setbacks between New Delhi and Washington. Another factor was Washington’s rapprochement with Pakistan, which brought fissures. The key issues for New Delhi were trade, tariffs, visa norms, and racism against Indians, which created bottlenecks.

Before the mid-term elections, Elbridge A. Colby, Secretary of War for the U.S., had delivered a mid-term assessment about the administration’s evaluation of the National Defense Strategy (NDS). A key focus was building the defence industry, strengthening homeland security, deterring China, support from allies, and the wider geopolitical impact. But foreign policy in the midterms became a local issue. Tariffs on partner countries, the war in Iran, fuel prices, and U.S. support for Israel were matters of contention.

The most recent development was the NVIDIA fiasco.

The most debated topic in Washington has been the governance of Artificial Intelligence (AI). Kat Duffy, a senior fellow for digital and cyberspace policy and director of LEAD AI at the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), spoke on a podcast about cyberspace policies, platform governance, privacy, corporate governance, and the CHIPS Act. Analysts are evaluating European regulatory systems and the potential threat from Chinese entities.

With the war in Iran, the leading AI firm Anthropic and its relationship with the U.S. government were in conflict. America’s leading behemoths such as Boeing, Lockheed, Google and Palantir have a wide industrial base. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth spoke about supply chain risks and the potential threats posed by adversaries.

China has made advancements in technology. The Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST) and the Ministry of Commerce (MOFCOM) had proposed AI, biomedicine, rare earth materials, and semiconductor technologies to China’s list of restricted exports. Chinese AI labs have released models as capable as Anthropic’s Claude or OpenAI’s GPT, at cost-effective prices. At the World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization (WAICO), Beijing has advanced cooperation among members while geopolitics takes centre stage. The new theatre will be the Indo-Pacific, where New Delhi and Washington seek convergence.

India and the United States have built a robust partnership over the last three decades. Despite differences, there has been bipartisan consensus in Congress and Washington over India’s role in the Indo-Pacific. New Delhi has always valued ‘Strategic Autonomy’ and is aligned towards mutual interests.

With the U.S. midterms, a lot has transpired between the Democrats and the Republicans. The Iran war remains contested while geopolitical events unfold. As foreign policy is leadership-driven, forecasting becomes complex. Disputes would necessitate deft diplomacy aimed at resolution. A lot will depend on the U.S. Congress and conflicts evolving in Asia. The recent summit in Manila is a key event, but the real challenge lies in holding the Quad together.

The writer is a foreign affairs analyst and columnist based in Bangalore.

Exit mobile version