By Dhurjati Mukherjee
Prime Minister Narendra Modi, speaking in Chhattisgarh’s Bastar region, used ‘dimaagi Naxals’ rhetoric while countering the ‘vote chori’ campaign. He accused Maoists of infiltrating political parties and inciting people against the Constitution and democracy. Bastar remains backward. If people rise to demand their rights, even through violent resistance against exploitation, should they be dismissed in this manner?
The remarks come as the government has proposed changes to Antyodaya entitlements. A July proposal reportedly reduced the 35-kg household grain entitlement to seven kg per person monthly, arguing that household-based allocation created inequities depending on family size.
The government has repeatedly celebrated its campaign to crush Naxalism. Ending armed insurgency is welcome, but the revolt of tribals also reflected decades of neglect and unmet developmental needs. Clearing forests of Maoists may be presented as an achievement, but what of the environmental cost and people whose livelihoods depend on those forests?
Official figures reportedly show that between 2024 and March 2026, 706 Naxals were killed, while 2,218 surrendered and 4,839 were arrested. What rehabilitation has been provided to those who surrendered and their families? Analysts condemn Maoist killings of political opponents and people branded class enemies. Yet allegations of torture and extrajudicial killings by security personnel also demand scrutiny. Violence cannot substitute for justice.
The movement emerged from the exploitation of tribal communities and poor people living around forests. Successive Central and state governments did little to address their grievances. Can people be expected to endure poverty indefinitely without resisting injustice? Equally troubling is the use of labels such as ‘urban Naxals’ and ‘dimaagi Naxals’. Intellectuals, lawyers and activists have been arrested or harassed over alleged links with the movement, although many say they worked for tribal, labour and civil rights.
In a pluralist democracy, citizens must be free to protest peacefully. The police must treat demonstrators lawfully and refrain from unnecessary force. The government must explain whether surrendered Maoists can rebuild their lives with basic necessities, rehabilitation and livelihood opportunities.
Remote, tribal-dominated regions such as Bastar need comprehensive development plans ensuring education, healthcare, infrastructure and decent livelihoods. Former President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam’s PURA initiative, or Providing Urban Amenities in Rural Areas, sought to bring essential facilities to villages, echoing Mahatma Gandhi’s emphasis on rural rejuvenation. Government priorities appear to favour cities, while remote communities continue to wait for basic services.
The neglect of rural India has been a persistent failure of successive governments. Urban-centric planning has not served adivasis, Dalits and other marginalised communities. Despite changes in strategy, comprehensive rural rejuvenation and balanced development remain unfulfilled goals. Development in backward regions should have preceded security operations, not followed them.
Another troubling trend is the criticism of academics, students and young people who support protests or question government policies. Branding dissenters with labels weakens democratic debate. Metropolitan-focused development, alongside inadequate investment in education and healthcare, has intensified frustration among young people. For families emerging from extreme poverty, education and health expenses consume a substantial share of income.
The government cannot dismiss those speaking against exploitation and injustice by branding them enemies. It must address the conditions fuelling discontent through equitable development, social infrastructure and respect for civil liberties. Weakening armed insurgency will remain an incomplete achievement unless marginalised communities gain security, dignity and opportunity.
Can the present dispensation prioritise impoverished communities and those supporting their legitimate demands, rather than resorting to name-calling? In a pluralist democracy, peaceful dissent cannot be ignored, harassed or criminalised. Upholding the Constitution requires listening to criticism and confronting deprivation. Leaders must move beyond labels and deliver a plan to rejuvenate remote and backward regions.