Odisha News, Odisha Latest news, Odisha Daily - OrissaPOST
  • Home
  • State
  • Metro
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Feature
  • Timeout
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Sci-Tech
  • Others
    • COVID-19
    • Today’s Pic
  • Home
  • State
  • Metro
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Feature
  • Timeout
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Sci-Tech
  • Others
    • COVID-19
    • Today’s Pic
No Result
View All Result
OrissaPOST - Odisha Latest news, English Daily -
No Result
View All Result

Judicial overreach for uniform civil code

Updated: July 15th, 2021, 08:00 IST
in Opinion
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare on Linkedin

SN Misra


Justice Prathiba M Singh of the Delhi High Court while hearing an estranged couple’s plea for divorce has observed that a common code for all citizens as expressed in Article 44 of the Constitution “ought not to remain a hope, but become a reality.” She was referring to the landmark Shah Bano case verdict wherein the Supreme Court in 1985 had observed: “A common civil code would help the cause of national integration by removing disparate loyalties to laws having conflicting ideologies.” The SC had observed that Article 44 of the Constitution has remained a dead letter and there is no evidence of any official activity for framing a civil code for the country.

The Shah Bano verdict was the first challenge to the Muslim Personal Law (1937) which denied maintenance to indigent divorced Muslim women. Then CJI YV Chandrachud had observed that the right to equality and absence of discrimination against women enshrined in Articles 14 & 15 equally apply to Muslim women. Section 125 of CrPC, which provides for maintenance to divorced women, would override archaic and patriarchal Muslim Personal Law. However, the contentious part of the judgement was its direction to the government to bring in a uniform civil code at the earliest. The court referred to Dr Tahir Mahmood’s scholarly book on Muslim Personal Law which says: “In pursuance of the goal of secularism, the State must stop administration of religion-based personal laws… Instead of wasting energies in exerting political and theological pressure… the Muslims will do well to begin exploring and demonstrating how the true Islamic laws, purged of their time-worn and anachronistic interpretations, can enrich the common civil code of India.”

The court has been assiduously following this line of argument in subsequent judgements like the Sarla Mudgal judgement, 1995, where Justice Kuldip Singh had observed: “When 80 per cent of the citizens have already been brought under the codified personal law, there is no justification to keep in abeyance introduction of a uniform civil code.” In Lily Thomas Case, 2000, the desirability of a uniform civil code particularly in regard to succession was reiterated. In ADC vs. NCT (2015), the SC lamented the absence of a uniform civil code with regard to guardianship of a Christian child.

Interestingly, the Law Commission of India in its report in August 2018 had stated that a uniform civil code is neither necessary nor desirable at this stage. “Secularism cannot contradict the plurality prevalent in the country,” the Commission said.
In this backdrop it would be useful to look at the larger picture of conflicting provisions in the Constitution and the contrarian viewpoint of academia and activists who are opposed to introduction of a uniform civil code. The Constitution has clearly provided in Articles 25 and 26 the right to profess, practice and propagate religion to all. On the other hand, Article 44 is an invocation to the State to endeavour for introduction of a uniform civil code. Therefore, introduction of a uniform civil code would be a clear negation of fundamental rights given to religious minorities.

The idea of achieving common Indian identity is undesirable because Indian identity is plural and a synthesis of differing views. Detractors believe that instead of a uniform social code, the state should attempt to bring in substantive equality at all levels and promote socio-economic justice for all.

Flavia Agnes, a well-known women’s rights activist, believes that uniformity has not worked well for women in India. Rather than uniformity, women need an accessible and affordable justice delivery system and inclusive model of development. Prof Nivedita Menon believes that national integrity as a rational for a uniform civil code along with its conflation with women’s rights is unacceptable because of its implicit homogenising thrust. She strongly advocates reforms in personal laws which are patently unjust.
The above perspective clearly brings home the inherent dangers of cultural homogenisation, given the plurality of Indian society. The Sarla Mudgal judgement made a sobering observation: “The desirability of uniform civil code can hardly be doubted. But it can concretise only when social climate is properly built up by elite of the society; statesmen amongst leaders who instead of gaining personal mileage rise above and awaken the masses to accept the change.”

Given the divisive times that we live in, respecting plurality in practice of personal laws rather than foisting Hindutva under the guise of a uniform civil code would be advisable. Promoting socio-economic justice, transcending religious consideration should be the predominant remit of the government. The judiciary should not be seen as promoting a uniform civil code at a time when the pluralistic fabric of India is under severe strain.

The writer teaches Constitutional Law.

Tags: SN MisraUniform Civil Code
ShareTweetSendShare
Suggest A Correction

Enter your email to get our daily news in your inbox.

Related Posts

Taming nature

April 30, 2023
Bhagat Singh photographed secretly at Lahore police station during his first arrest and detention from May 29 to July 4, 1927.

Despatches from a neglected past

April 20, 2023

Voters & ideology

April 6, 2023

Time to criminalise marital rape

March 7, 2023
(File photo of Melvin Durai via facebook.com/humorcolumns)

Money can’t buy everything for Qatar

November 30, 2022
(File photo of Melvin Durai via facebook.com/humorcolumns)

Aliens keep looking down on Earth

October 13, 2022

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

OrissaPOST epaper Sunday POST OrissaPOST epaper

Click Here: Plastic Free Odisha

Plastic Free Odisha

Ratikant Mohapatra,Odissi Dance Director

Ratikant Mohapatra support a plastic free odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Nayagarh Girls’ High School

Nayagarh Girls’ High School students support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Debashish Mohanty-Former Indian Cricketer

Cricketer Debashish Mohanty supports  a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Students of Tulasipur Saraswati Sishu Vidya Mandir, Cuttack

Students of Tulasipur Saraswati Sishu Vidya Mandir, Cuttack call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

National School Kujang

National School students Kujang Jagatsinghpur district support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Sri Aurobindo School students & teachers

Sri Aurobindo School students & teachers of Sambalpur support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Unit III Bharat Scouts and Guide

Unit III Bharat Scouts and Guides team call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Sundargarh Public School students

Sundargarh Public School students support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Gandhi College Plus III science students of Khandagiri, Bhubaneswar

Gandhi Plus III science students of Khandagiri, Bhubaneswar support a plastic free Odisha. Do you?   *Visit our website orissapost.com. ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Darsheel Safary, Actor

Darsheel Safary calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website www.orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Arindam Roy, Actor

Arindam Roy supports call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website www.orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

D.A.V Public School-Kalinga Nagar

D.A.V Public School Students, support Plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Samanta Singhara Nodal High School students

Samanta Singhara Nodal High School students of Balia, Jajpur support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Sundargarh Public School teachers

Sundargarh Public School teachers support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Olympian Anuradha Biswal

Olympian Anuradha Biswal supports a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Balibil Nodal School students

Balibil Nodal School students support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Cuttack College NCC students

Cuttack College NCC students support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Odisha Rajya Rogi Adhikar Mancha & Mangalabagh International Club workers

Odisha Rajya Rogi Adhikar Mancha & Mangalabagh International Club Workers support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Members of All Ride Bicycle

Members of All Ride Bicycle supports a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Bijay Mohanty, Actor

Actor Bijay Mohanty calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Have You Joined the movement? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Srikumar Misra-Entrepreneur

Srikumar Misra supports a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Archita Sahu, Actress

Archita Sahu support a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Cuttack New Stewart School Students & Principal

Cuttack New Stewart School students and Principal call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

CRPF 127 Battalion, Bhanjanagar

CRPF 127 Battalion, Bhanjanagar supports a plastic free Odisha. Do you?   *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Bargarh Ranapratap High School students

Bargarh Ranapratap High School students support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Akash Dasnayak, Actor

Akash Dasnayak, Actor supports a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

IMT Pharmacy College-Puri

IMT Pharmacy College students call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Have You Joined the movement? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Swaraj Barik, Actor

Swaraj Barik calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website www.orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Hockey Player Dilip Tirkey

Hockey Player Dilip Tirkey supports a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Olympian Dutee Chand

Olympian Dutee Chand calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Have You Joined the movement? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our ...

August 30, 2018

Archives

Editorial

Sedition Law Mockery

(PC: legalvidhiya.com)
June 5, 2023

The Law Commission’s “considered” opinion that Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) pertaining to sedition laws should be...

Read more

Juvenile & Unreal

June 4, 2023

A story was reported on 2 June with the headline “Bengal couple accused of being ‘Bangladeshi infiltrators’ freed from Bengaluru...

Read more

Void in Doha

June 3, 2023

For nearly two months, the position of Indian ambassador in Doha has remained unoccupied, leaving a big void in the...

Read more

Film & Falsehood

A screenshot of teaser of Swatantrya Veer Savarkar. (PC: Randeep Hooda/Facebook)
May 31, 2023

There is yet another film claiming “real life” story and yet another instance of falsification of facts to suit a...

Read more
  • Home
  • State
  • Metro
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Feature
  • Sports
  • Sci-Tech
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Career
Developed By Ratna Technology

© 2020 All rights Reserved by OrissaPOST

  • Home
  • Metro
  • State
  • National
  • International
  • IPL
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Feature
  • Opinion
  • Sci-Tech
  • COVID-19
  • Today’s Pic
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Career
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

© 2020 All rights Reserved by OrissaPOST