Odisha News, Odisha Latest news, Odisha Daily - OrissaPOST
  • Home
  • State
  • Metro
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Feature
  • Timeout
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Sci-Tech
  • Others
    • COVID-19
    • Today’s Pic
  • Home
  • State
  • Metro
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Feature
  • Timeout
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Sci-Tech
  • Others
    • COVID-19
    • Today’s Pic
No Result
View All Result
OrissaPOST - Odisha Latest news, English Daily -
No Result
View All Result

Untying the Hong Kong knot

The unrest in Hong Kong can be addressed effectively by means of a citizens’ assembly, as it holds the best promise for a just and fair outcome for all stakeholders

Updated: August 13th, 2019, 09:13 IST
in Opinion
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare on Linkedin

Dhanada Kanta Mishra


Hong Kong’s season of unrest seems to be overflowing. What started with mammoth non-violent protests against the infamous amendment proposed to the extradition bill is, with its unprecedented violence fast transforming into a kind of ‘civil war’. Far from the original issue of the withdrawal of the extremely unpopular amendment proposal, it is now about the resignation of the chief executive, the accountability of the police force and even the very future of Hong Kong under the one country, two systems rule. The society is more divided than ever, with a pro-establishment faction trying to match the strength, if not passion, of the protesters by not only holding demonstrations in support of the police actions and the bill but, most recently, seemingly resorting to outright violence. Such violence has not spared even innocent bystanders.

Many have proposed different ways to help address the contentious issue and avoid further violence and possible bloodshed. Most declarations by the chief executive, including of the suspension of the bill, have not been able to placate the youth and students, whose trust deficit is too wide to be bridged with mere words. Academicians, including presidents of universities, have volunteered to facilitate talks between the government and protesters. Some have suggested extended jurisdiction for Hong Kong courts as one way around the vexed issue. But none of the proposals seemingly has the power to heal the wounds and find widespread acceptance. In such a situation, outside-the-box thinking is required for a possible resolution, learning from successful examples in the rest of the world.

Ireland is well known for its traditionally conservative catholic society, which for a long time was staunchly opposed to abortion under any circumstance and refused recognition of same-sex marriages. Ireland’s Citizens’ Assembly (https://www.citizensassembly.ie/en/), formed in 2016, broke the deadlock on both these controversial issues. The recommendations of the assembly informed public debate and emboldened politicians to advocate for change.

A citizens’ assembly brings a small representative group of people together to learn, deliberate and make recommendations on an issue of public concern. Similar to jury service, members are randomly selected from the population by a process called sortition. Stratified sampling techniques are used to ensure that the assembly is representative in terms of key characteristics such as gender, age, ethnicity, education level and geography. Assembly members learn about critical thinking before they hear balanced information from experts and stakeholders. The members spend time deliberating in small, facilitated groups and then draft and vote on recommendations. Citizens’ assemblies are conducted by non-partisan organisations under independent oversight. They are transparent, inclusive and effective. Such assemblies are being used around the world in countries such as the UK, Canada, and Australia. They have demonstrated that the general public can understand complex information, deliberate on options and make fair and impartial choices. Citizens’ assemblies are often used to address issues that are deemed too controversial and difficult for politicians to deal with successfully by themselves.

In Hong Kong’s form of democracy, power lies in the hands of a few representatives, the majority of whom are not even directly elected by the people. The short electoral cycles of up to five years in the system of representative democracy discourage governments from attending to issues with long-term implications, such as the current crisis. Democratic representatives are lobbied by powerful corporations, seek sympathetic media coverage and calculate their policies based on the potential reaction of the media and the public, as measured by opinion polls. This means politicians often feel unable to propose the bold changes necessary to address an emergency.

The formation of a properly constituted citizens’ assembly would to a large extent restore the broken trust in governance. It would give all parties to the conflict a break, as the process takes its time. It would break the deadlock by giving politicians access to public judgements that have been reached in a fair and informed way. This would help politicians commit to actions justified by the mandate they receive from the citizens’ assembly, reducing the potential public backlash at the ballot box.

Citizens’ assemblies can be used when difficult trade-offs are necessary. For example, experts might propose policies on how to replace the proposed amendment to the extradition law with a number of more acceptable legal frameworks, and the citizens in the assembly would then decide which one they prefer. For example, they might recommend a referendum with clear terms of reference, as was the case in Ireland. Eventually, the referendum outcome in support of lifting the restrictions on abortion was very close to the vote in the 100-member assembly.

Hong Kong is passing through a critical phase of turmoil. The youth are disturbed to their core, uncertain about the outcome of the current events and their eventual future. On top of anxieties regarding the mainland’s interference in the island’s affairs, economic pressures, growing inequality and a lack of affordable housing are all adding to the expression of frustration on the streets. Their concerns need to be handled with the utmost sensitivity and care. Among all the options available, a citizens’ assembly holds the best promise for a just and fair outcome for all stakeholders, while also healing the wounds inflicted by the prolonged disturbance and conflict. It is the best vehicle to make the wide-ranging dialogue with all sections of society often promised by the chief executive a reality.

The writer holds a doctorate in civil engineering from the University of Michigan and is a professor of Civil Engineering at Biju Patnaik University of Technology and Principal of KMBB College of Engineering and Technology. He is currently visiting the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology as a Research Scholar.

 

Tags: citizens' assemblyDhanada Kanta MishraHong Kong protestsOpinionORISSA POST
ShareTweetSendShare
Suggest A Correction

Enter your email to get our daily news in your inbox.

Related Posts

(File photo of Melvin Durai via facebook.com/humorcolumns)

Ride a bicycle & make a statement

June 15, 2022
Digital lending has emerged as an effective alternative to traditional lending (by financial institutions) for people who are new to credit or are underserved by the financial system. (Photo: Reuters)

Changing the way banking is done

May 26, 2022
Representational image

Creating a seamless farmers’ database

May 16, 2022
Prime Minister Narendra Modi with counterparts from Nordic countries. (Twitter/@narendramodi)

Takeaways for India

May 7, 2022

No shortcuts?

May 6, 2022

Snobbery of stomach

April 29, 2022

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

OrissaPOST epaper Sunday POST OrissaPOST epaper

Click Here: Plastic Free Odisha

Plastic Free Odisha

Ratikant Mohapatra,Odissi Dance Director

Ratikant Mohapatra support a plastic free odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Sundargarh Public School students

Sundargarh Public School students support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Anubhav Mohanty, Actor

Anubhav Mohanty supports call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website www.orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Darsheel Safary, Actor

Darsheel Safary calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website www.orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Swaraj Barik, Actor

Swaraj Barik calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website www.orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

BJB Autonomous College-Bhubaneswar

BJB Autonomous college students support a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Actor Sritam Das

Actor Sritam Das supports a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Arindam Roy, Actor

Arindam Roy supports call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website www.orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Srikumar Misra-Entrepreneur

Srikumar Misra supports a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Haratiya Bidyaniketan School students

Haratiya Bidyaniketan School students of Alipur, Bari support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Balibil Nodal School students

Balibil Nodal School students support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Sabyasachi Mishra, Actor

Sabyasachi Mishra calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website www.orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Govinda Poddar-Odisha Ranji Team Captain

Govinda Poddar, Odisha Ranji Team Captain  calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Have You Joined the movement? *Visit our website ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Kalamatia Sahid Bidyapitha students

Kalamatia Sahid Bidyapitha students support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

October 2, 2018
Covaxin
Christmas

Bharat Biotech rubbishes criticism, says its vaccine is safe    

New Delhi/Hyderabad: Hyderabad-based Bharat Biotech rejected Monday criticism over the grant of emergency use authorisation by India’s drug regulator to ...

January 5, 2021
Plastic Free Odisha

Sri Aurobindo School students & teachers

Sri Aurobindo School students & teachers of Sambalpur support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Sundargarh Public School teachers

Sundargarh Public School teachers support a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Padmashree Aruna Mohanty-Odissi Dancer

Padmashree Odissi Dancer Aruna Mohanty calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Have You Joined the movement? *Visit our website orissapost.com. ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Olympian Anuradha Biswal

Olympian Anuradha Biswal supports a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Sports Person Sradhanjali Samantaray

Sports Personality Sradhanjali Samantaray support a *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your Photos/Selfie (with fingers ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

IMT Pharmacy College-Puri

IMT Pharmacy College students call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Have You Joined the movement? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Cuttack New Stewart School Students & Principal

Cuttack New Stewart School students and Principal call for a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you support the movement? *Visit our website ...

August 29, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Tanbhi Block School students and staff

Tanbhi Block School students and staff support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Bijay Mohanty, Actor

Actor Bijay Mohanty calls for a Plastic Free Odisha. Have You Joined the movement? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

D.A.V Public School-Kalinga Nagar

D.A.V Public School Students, support Plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Hockey Player Dilip Tirkey

Hockey Player Dilip Tirkey supports a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Bridge school students

Bridge school students support plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Members of All Ride Bicycle

Members of All Ride Bicycle supports a plastic free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page ...

October 2, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Miteish Khimji,Entrepreneur

Miteish Khimji supports a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you? *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your ...

August 30, 2018
Plastic Free Odisha

Naveen Jindal-Enterpreneur

Naveen Jindal support a Plastic Free Odisha. Do you?  *Visit our website orissapost.com. Like,Share,Subscribe,Recommend our Facebook Page Orissapost(@OrissaPOST.Here.Now) *Post your Photos/Selfie ...

August 30, 2018

Archives

Editorial

Shortage of Officers

June 25, 2022

The Uttarakhand government has been struggling to work with only 76 IAS officers in the state, even though it has...

Read more

Disarm All Nukes

June 23, 2022

Austria and New Zealand may be far apart geographically, but we are connected by shared values and principles. Particularly relevant...

Read more

Fractured France

Picture Credit: 
The Arab Weekly
June 22, 2022

French politics is thrown into turmoil after President Emmanuel Macron lost control of the National Assembly in legislative elections in which...

Read more

China & LeT

(PC: Reuters)
June 21, 2022

India has cried foul over China’s decision to put on hold UN listing of Lashkar-e-Taiba’s (LeT) second-in-command Abdul Rehman Makki....

Read more
  • Home
  • State
  • Metro
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Feature
  • Sports
  • Sci-Tech
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Career
Developed By Ratna Technology

© 2020 All rights Reserved by OrissaPOST

  • Home
  • Metro
  • State
  • National
  • International
  • IPL
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Feature
  • Opinion
  • Sci-Tech
  • COVID-19
  • Today’s Pic
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Career
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

© 2020 All rights Reserved by OrissaPOST